Griswold Cake Recipes

Griswold Cake Recipes


(from  AUNT  ELLEN’S COOKBOOK” insert for GRISWOLD cake molds)

By Doris Mosier


½ CUP SHORTENING                                                      2 ½ CUPS FLOUR

1 ½ CUPS SUGAR                                                            4 TSPS. BAKING POWDER

3 EGGS                                                                               ½ TSP. SALT

1 CUP MILK                                                                       1 TSP. VANILLA

Cream shortening, add sugar gradually. Cream well. Add well-beaten yolks and cream again. Alternately add the dry ingredients, which have been sifted together, and then milk to which the flavoring has  been added. Lastly, carefully fold in beaten egg whites.  Bake on face 25 minutes and on back 20 minutes. Placing a toothpick in each ear will support that portion of the cake.


1 ½ CUPS WHITE SUGAR                                             FLAVORING

1 CUP WATER                                                               WHITES OF 2 EGGS


Boil sugar and water until it threads. Beat whites of two eggs, stiff. Pour syrup over egg whites gradually. Beat until cool. Ice cake all over and throw on the coconut. Use raisins for the eyes and a piece of candied cherry or raisin for the mouth.


1 ½ CUPS CHOPPED DATES                           1 ½ TEASPOONS VANILLA

1 ½ CUPS BOILING WATER                            2 ½ CUPS FLOUR

1 ½ CUPS SUGAR                                              ½ TEASPOON SALT

½ CUP BUTTER                                                 1 ½ TEASPOONS SODA

2 EGGS                                                                ½ CUP CHOPPED NUTS

Mix dates with boiling water and cool to lukewarm.  Cream butter and sugar.  Add eggs and vanilla and beat well.  Combine with date mixture.  Add flour sifted with salt and soda.  Beat well.  Add nut meats. Bake in well-greased and lightly floured Santa Claus mold twenty-five minutes on face, then twenty minutes on back, in moderate oven.  Iced or plain as preferred.

Nickel plated cast iron Santa and the cast iron Santa — all three molds at the bottom of this section.


This is from the 1929 Griswold booklet, so change to suit your 21st century style of baking.

½ Cup Shortening
2 Cups Brown Sugar
2 Eggs
1 Cup Sour Milk
2 ½ Cups Pastry Flour
2 Tablespoons Cinnamon
1 teaspoons Allspice
½ teaspoon Cloves
1 teaspoon Nutmeg
1 teaspoon Soda

Cream shortening, and add sugar gradually while creaming.  Work smooth all lumps.  Add well beaten eggs and beat well.  Sift together dry ingredients and add to mixture alternately with sour milk.  Bake in a well greased and lightly floured Santa Claus mold 25 minutes on face side, then 20 minutes on the back in moderate oven.  Frost with any desired icing.


2 ½ Cups Granulated Sugar
½ Cup Light Corn Syrup
½ Cup Water
2 Egg whites
1 ½ teaspoons Vanilla

Boil sugar, syrup and water to softball stage.  Pour slowly over stiffly beaten egg whites.  Beat constantly.  Add the vanilla and beat until almost cold and stiff enough to hold shape.

(This icing may be kept in a covered jar for a week.  If necessary, use boiling water to soften).

For chocolate icing, add to the above 4 squares of bitter chocolate which has been melted.  You can add the chocolate anytime after the hot syrup has been poured over the egg whites.

For red icing, take part of white icing and add vegetable coloring.  If needed, add powdered sugar for proper consistency.

HINT ONE:  I’m not too successful as a cake baker period, but I’ve been told from a very reliable source that you NEED to heat these oiled  molds a bit, dust with flour before adding the batter. Bunny Baker never uses the molds cold.

HINT TWO:  Fill the largest half of the mold within ¾ of the top—not more.  Put the other half on top, empty!

HINT THREE:  Get real—o.k. if you REALLY want to be authentic on the ingredients, but I’m all for using a boxed cake mix and canned icing—I know it’s not quite the same, but I’m not into pain either.   My friend, Sue Conron claims that DROMEDARY Pound Cake mix is great for these molds—just a perfect consistency.

HINT FOUR—if you do the rabbit mold cake, even Aunt Ellen says to reinforce the ears by placing toothpicks in each ear before you bake the batter, unless you’re into floppy eared rabbits.

HINT FIVE—leftover batter makes good cupcakes!

HINT SIX—you can SOUR milk by adding 1 teaspoon of vinegar to regular milk.

…….and I’m available for sampling your baking results!

Related Posts

Top Prices Realized at July 19 – 20, 2018 Vintage and Antique Cast Iron Auction in Richmond, Missouri

Top Prices Realized at July 19 – 20, 2018 Vintage and Antique Cast Iron Auction in Richmond, Missouri

These are the top prices realized at the Simmons and Company Auctioneers cast iron auction on July 20 – 21, 2018 in Richmond, Missouri. I got photos of most of the pieces, but unfortunately not all of them. $1875: Griswold large block logo no. 13 […]

Doyle and Brenda’s Collection, Cooking, and Brenda’s Mad Cake-Making Skills

Doyle and Brenda’s Collection, Cooking, and Brenda’s Mad Cake-Making Skills

Fellow cast iron enthusiasts Brenda Bernstein and Doyle Pregler live in New London, Minnesota, a small community about two hours northwest of the Twin Cities. They have been together 28 years, have 6 grown children between them, and 12 grandchildren ages 3 to 19. If […]

Send this to a friend